I got into an argument about the show and why? The thing is I would have given the show to Archuleta too and I agree that if we were to judge from last night alone, then the younger David was the winner. I went into this night already committed that the better singer and performer was by far the older David Cook. But his performance on finals night was dismal and he should have lost. I argued that the judgment is about awarding the best based on overall performance throughout the season and if we continue to leave this decision in the hands of the Internet and tele-texting public then judging will always be base on the overall and not the finals night alone. If you woo the American all year long and got their support then you are bound to receive it on Finals night too.